Wednesday 8 February 2012, The Bloomsbury Hotel, London
Carbon Capture & Storage Forum
09.00
Welcome address by Marketforce
David Saunders
Managing Director, Marketforce
Biography
David Saunders is Managing Director of Marketforce Business Media, which he founded (as Marketforce Communications) in 1987.
Amongst his roles at Marketforce he acts as editorial director of conferences in markets subject to economic regulation, including energy and utilities, broadcasting and postal services. He has led the development of Marketforce conferences in the postal services market in Europe and the UK for the last thirteen years.
He also leads Marketforce's public relations and communications service in the business to business market.
David Saunders is a graduate in law from the University of Durham and a barrister.
For 25 years he was a Royal Naval Reserve officer, becoming the most junior Commanding Officer in the Royal Navy at the age of 27. He subsequently commanded 6 HM Ships and acted as Minewarfare adviser to the UK Permanent Joint Headquarters.
09.05
Chairman’s opening remarks
Prof Stuart Haszeldine
Scottish Power Professor of CCS, University of Edinburgh
Session One: Developing CCS in the UK – a roadmap to commercialisation
09.10
Keynote opening address: Towards demonstrating CCS in the UK
Adam Dawson
Chief Executive, Office of Carbon Capture & Storage
Biography
Adam is Chief Executive and Director of the Office of Carbon Capture & Storage. The OCCS was created in March 2010 and Adam joined in April. The OCCS's role is to facilitate the delivery of CCS as a key carbon abatement technology in the UK for both power generation and industrial applications, and to help promote UK opportunities in the rapid deployment of CCS internationally. Adam joined the OCCS after three and a half years as Head of New Nuclear in DECC's Office for Nuclear Development. One of his team's key achievements was to publish a White Paper on the future of nuclear power, after a major public consultation taking the best part of a year. This opened up the prospect of new nuclear power stations being built in the UK for the first time in 20 years. Prior to joining the Civil Service in 2005, Adam spent 19 years working for Shell, primarily in the area of bulk petrochemicals.
09.35
Panel Discussion: Strategic Forum – challenges and strategies details
- Assessing the state of play: where is the UK compared to the rest of the world?
- What are the challenges to making CCS economically viable?
- Examining the most promising projects: what are the timelines?
- Are competition requirements realistic and effective?
- Is there enough clarity on policy and regulation to proceed with CCS projects?
- What are the implications of the Energy White Paper for CCS?
- Creating the right conditions for CCS: will there be a “coal renaissance”?
- Will a dash for gas impede CCS development?
- Minimising counter-party risk: identifying the best models for governance
Questions from the audience
Muir Miller
Project Director, Ayrshire Power, Peel Energy
Biography
Muir Miller is Managing Director of Peel Energy having joined the company as Business DevelopmentDirector in 2008. Initially taking responsibility for delivery of Peel’s portfolio of thermal developmentprojects and operations within the wind energy portfolio, he became Managing Director in 2010 andnow has over-all responsibility for the Energy division, working closely with the Non-ExecutiveChairman and Peel Group Board.
Muir is a Chartered Engineer, specialising in mechanical engineering, with wide experience in anumber of sectors including marine engineering, petrochemicals, infrastructure and utilities. Hiscareer in renewable energy began at United Utilities Green Energy in 2003, having already spent tenyears with United Utilities leading large scale infrastructure projects in the Far East. On returning tothe UK he became Operations Director for United Utilities’ portfolio of land fill gas, wind and hydropower assets.
When United Utilities Green Energy and Novera Energy Limited were acquired by Macquarie Bank,Muir took a leading role in the corporate transaction, and subsequently in his role as Chief ExecutiveOfficer of the newly formed Novera Macquarie Renewable Energy. He took executive responsibilityfor the successful delivery of profit and loss performance and cash distribution targets as well asmasterminding the integration and working practice merger programme for the new organisation.
In 2007 Muir was appointed by Macquarie to the role of Business Development Director at EnergyPower Resources Limited where Muir led the development of the company’s asset base by creating arobust project pipeline including several thermal generation projects which now form part of EPRL’soperating portfolio.
Outside the corporate environment Muir takes an active role in the local community, sitting on theboard of Trafford College of Further Education. He graduated from the University of Strathclyde inGlasgow and subsequently undertook an MBA at the prestigious Warwick Business School.
Arne de Kock
UK CCS Project Director, Shell U.K. Limited
Biography
Arne de Kock was born in the famous cheese city of Alkmaar, The Netherlands, some 46 years ago. He graduated in 1988 from the University of Technology, Delft, with a MSc in Petroleum Engineering, and joined Shell International E&P that same year. After assignments in Muscat, Aberdeen, Warri, The Hague, New Orleans, London, Rio de Janeiro, and Mexico City, currently based in Aberdeen, Scotland again. Moved from an initial career in Petrophysical & Reservoir Engineering to Gas Commercial in 1998, and from there to New Business Development & Joint Venture Governance in Gas & Power in Brazil from 2000-2004, followed by a role as VP Commercial LNG in Mexico from 2004-2007. Since returning back to the UK in 2007, acted as Senior Commercial Discipline Lead until 2009, prior to the current role as CCS Project Director for the Longannet-to-Goldeneye CCS Project, which is presently undergoing an 11-month FEED study after having won Funding from the UK Government in the 1st UK CCS Competition.
In his spare time, Arne and his Mexican wife, Evelyn, thoroughly enjoy everything that Scotland has to offer; the people, the culture, the food (hmm?), the spectacular outdoors (hiking & biking), the golf, and so on. They are now in great anticipation for the arrival of their first baby in early January 2011.
Steve Waygood
Head of Environment & Chemistry, npower
Biography
Dr Steve Waygood is RWE npower’s Head of Environment & Chemistry. Principally accountable for the leadership of the Environment & Chemistry team, Dr Waygood’s wide remit also sees him take responsibility for the delivery of RWE power’s R&D programme in the UK. With the launch and operation of the carbon capture pilot plant at Aberthaw the most significant element of the R&D programme at present, Dr Waygood is closely involved in R&D at a Group level and plays a key role in the development and implementation of the company’s carbon capture strategy across Europe.
Lewis Gillies
Chief Executive, 2Co Energy
Biography
Lewis Gillies is Chief Executive and Co-Founder of 2Co Energy Ltd, the owner of the UK’s Don Valley CCS power project which also plans to use the captured CO2 in Enhanced Oil Recovery while also storing the CO2 permanently in oil fields.
Previously, Lewis served as Chief Executive of Hydrogen Energy International, the former BP/Rio Tinto CCS joint venture, and as head of the BP unit developing a number of leading CCS power projects – in Abu Dhabi, California and at Peterhead in Scotland.
Lewis joined BP in 1989 as a Chartered Engineer working on several BP petrochemical sites. Later he managed major capital projects before taking on greater commercial and leadership roles, soon running a number of BP business lines, and ultimately taking on senior management and executive roles at BP.
Session Two: Accelerating CCS development across Europe
10.50
Keynote address: Meeting Europe’s 2020 targets: an update on CCS details
- Is the EU on track for commercially demonstrating CCS by 2020?
- NER 300 competition update: what are the criteria for project selection?
- How has the EU Directive on geological storage of CO2 been transposed across Europe?
Jan Panek
Head of Unit Coal & Oil, EU Commission
Biography
Jan Panek is Head of Unit "Coal and Oil" in the Directorate-General for Energy of the European Commission in Brussels. He joined the European Commission in 2005 following an earlier career in the diplomatic service of the Czech Ministry of Foreign Affairs during which he occupied positions in the Ministry' headquarters as well as in Czech diplomatic missions in Tokyo and Brussels. He also spent several years in the 1990s with the Boston Consulting Group in its London and Central European offices. He holds a B.Sc. in Applied Geophysics from Charles University in Prague and an M.A. in International Economics/A.F.P. from The Johns Hopkins University – S.A.I.S. in Washington, D.C. He is also a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) charterholder.
11.20
Demonstration project 1: key lessons from Longannet-toGoldeneye details
- Undertaking the first UK competition: what were the challenges?
- Completing the FEED studies: an outline
- Moving ahead: can we now make Peterhead-to-Goldeneye a reality instead?
Arne de Kock
UK CCS Project Director, Shell U.K. Limited
Biography
Arne de Kock was born in the famous cheese city of Alkmaar, The Netherlands, some 46 years ago. He graduated in 1988 from the University of Technology, Delft, with a MSc in Petroleum Engineering, and joined Shell International E&P that same year. After assignments in Muscat, Aberdeen, Warri, The Hague, New Orleans, London, Rio de Janeiro, and Mexico City, currently based in Aberdeen, Scotland again. Moved from an initial career in Petrophysical & Reservoir Engineering to Gas Commercial in 1998, and from there to New Business Development & Joint Venture Governance in Gas & Power in Brazil from 2000-2004, followed by a role as VP Commercial LNG in Mexico from 2004-2007. Since returning back to the UK in 2007, acted as Senior Commercial Discipline Lead until 2009, prior to the current role as CCS Project Director for the Longannet-to-Goldeneye CCS Project, which is presently undergoing an 11-month FEED study after having won Funding from the UK Government in the 1st UK CCS Competition.
In his spare time, Arne and his Mexican wife, Evelyn, thoroughly enjoy everything that Scotland has to offer; the people, the culture, the food (hmm?), the spectacular outdoors (hiking & biking), the golf, and so on. They are now in great anticipation for the arrival of their first baby in early January 2011.
11.40
Undertaking gas CCS: an update from Peterhead details
- What work is currently being undertaken?
- Pre- and post-combustion: what are the technical differences for gas CCS?
- Competing with coal: what are the implications for funding?
- Does the NER300 provide adequate incentives for gas CCS?
Dr Keith MacLean
Policy & Research Director, SSE
Biography
Since completing graduate and postgraduate studies in Chemistry at Heriot-Watt and Hamburg Universities, Keith joined SSE in 1994 following a career in Germany and Scotland working in Research & Development and Business Management.
At SSE he has worked in a number of areas of the energy business and was also responsible for starting-up and running its telecoms business from 1997 to 2004. Since 2004 he has been responsible for policy and public affairs.
Outside SSE, he is a Director on the Board of the Scottish Renewables Forum (SRF) and is also Chairman of the Board at the UK Business Council for Sustainable Energy (UKBCSE).
In addition to this trade association activity he is a government advisor on renewable energy policy and was appointed to the Renewables Advisory Board in December 2007 and is also a member of the Scottish Government’s Forum for Renewable Energy.
12.00
Pathway to next generation capture technology details
- What work is currently being undertaken?
- Pre- and post-combustion: what are the technical differences for gas CCS?
- Competing with coal: what are the implications for funding?
- Does the NER300 provide adequate incentives for gas CCS?
Terry Tomlinson
General Manager Front End Solutions, Costain
Biography
Terry Tomlinson is General Manager Front End Solutions at Costain Energy and Process, Manchester, UK with overall responsibility for front-end process design activities. He has over 35 years experience in gas plant projects across a wide variety of applications including gas storage, reception, conditioning and distribution as well as cryogenic processing of industrial and hydrocarbon gas streams. He holds a B.Sc. in chemical engineering from Leeds University. He is a Fellow of the Institution of Chemical Engineers and a Chartered Engineer in the UK.
12.35
Introduction to the Adam Smith Institute
Session Three: Understanding the economics of CCS
13.55
The Electricity Market Reform White Paper: the right support for CCS? details
- How does the White Paper position CCS compared to other low-carbon technologies?
- Where is further clarity needed to promote CCS development?
- The EMR White Paper in practice: how will FITs, capacity mechanisms, EPS and the carbon price floor interact?
Prof. Jim Watson
Director, Sussex Energy Group
Biography
Professor Jim Watson is Director of the Sussex Energy Group, University of Sussex and a Research Fellow with the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research. He has over 15 years' experience of managing and conducting research on a range of energy and climate policy issues. His advisory roles include acting as lead expert with a UK Foresight project on Sustainable Energy Management and the Built Environment (2007-08), and as Specialist Adviser to two House of Commons select committees (2006-11). He was a Visiting Scholar at the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University in 2008. Jim is the 2011 chair of the British Institute for Energy Economics.
14.15
Attracting private financing for CCS: what needs to be done? details
- From capture to storage: where are the risks?
- Is achieving scalability the holy grail for investors?
- How can political risk be minimised?
- The impact of long-term CO2 liability for financing
Allan Baker
Global Head of Power, Société Générale
Biography
Allan has been involved in the power sector for more than 25 years, initially as an engineer but for the last 20 years in finance sector. During his career he has advised on and financed a wide range of projects in Asia, the US and EMEA ranging from renewable energy to the acquisition of large power portfolios. This experience has also encompassed regulated, partially deregulated and merchant power markets.
Allan has worked at Société Générale for four years as Global Head of Power Project Finance, having previously worked at Credit Lyonnais for thirteen years in various project finance and management roles. In his current role Allan leads the bank’s strategy for structured finance in the power sector and co-ordinates the execution of the global project finance and advisory business in the sector. As part of this role he is currently leading the bank’s development of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) as a potential business line and is acting as Financial Advisor to the Masdar CCS project in Abu Dhabi and Powerfuel Power IGCC/CCS project in the UK.
Allan has a BSc (Hons) in Mechanical Engineering, an MBA, is a Fellow of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers and a Chartered Engineer.
14.35
Ask the experts: Securing funding for CCS - Roundtable discussion details
Delegates will form discussion groups around their tables to discuss the critical factors to securing private and public funding for CCS. They will be asked to formulate comments and questions to pose to the panel in a feedback session after the roundtable discussions.
- What are the barriers for CCS funding?
- Is the EMR White Paper sending the right signals for CCS development?
- What should industry be doing to bring in private investors?
- Assessing the impact of developing technology in securing private financing
Allan Baker
Global Head of Power, Société Générale
Biography
Allan has been involved in the power sector for more than 25 years, initially as an engineer but for the last 20 years in finance sector. During his career he has advised on and financed a wide range of projects in Asia, the US and EMEA ranging from renewable energy to the acquisition of large power portfolios. This experience has also encompassed regulated, partially deregulated and merchant power markets.
Allan has worked at Société Générale for four years as Global Head of Power Project Finance, having previously worked at Credit Lyonnais for thirteen years in various project finance and management roles. In his current role Allan leads the bank’s strategy for structured finance in the power sector and co-ordinates the execution of the global project finance and advisory business in the sector. As part of this role he is currently leading the bank’s development of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) as a potential business line and is acting as Financial Advisor to the Masdar CCS project in Abu Dhabi and Powerfuel Power IGCC/CCS project in the UK.
Allan has a BSc (Hons) in Mechanical Engineering, an MBA, is a Fellow of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers and a Chartered Engineer.
Prof. Jim Watson
Director, Sussex Energy Group
Biography
Professor Jim Watson is Director of the Sussex Energy Group, University of Sussex and a Research Fellow with the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research. He has over 15 years' experience of managing and conducting research on a range of energy and climate policy issues. His advisory roles include acting as lead expert with a UK Foresight project on Sustainable Energy Management and the Built Environment (2007-08), and as Specialist Adviser to two House of Commons select committees (2006-11). He was a Visiting Scholar at the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University in 2008. Jim is the 2011 chair of the British Institute for Energy Economics.
Lewis Gillies
Chief Executive, 2Co Energy
Biography
Lewis Gillies is Chief Executive and Co-Founder of 2Co Energy Ltd, the owner of the UK’s Don Valley CCS power project which also plans to use the captured CO2 in Enhanced Oil Recovery while also storing the CO2 permanently in oil fields.
Previously, Lewis served as Chief Executive of Hydrogen Energy International, the former BP/Rio Tinto CCS joint venture, and as head of the BP unit developing a number of leading CCS power projects – in Abu Dhabi, California and at Peterhead in Scotland.
Lewis joined BP in 1989 as a Chartered Engineer working on several BP petrochemical sites. Later he managed major capital projects before taking on greater commercial and leadership roles, soon running a number of BP business lines, and ultimately taking on senior management and executive roles at BP.
14.55
Feedback and questions from the audience
Lewis Gillies
Chief Executive, 2Co Energy
Biography
Lewis Gillies is Chief Executive and Co-Founder of 2Co Energy Ltd, the owner of the UK’s Don Valley CCS power project which also plans to use the captured CO2 in Enhanced Oil Recovery while also storing the CO2 permanently in oil fields.
Previously, Lewis served as Chief Executive of Hydrogen Energy International, the former BP/Rio Tinto CCS joint venture, and as head of the BP unit developing a number of leading CCS power projects – in Abu Dhabi, California and at Peterhead in Scotland.
Lewis joined BP in 1989 as a Chartered Engineer working on several BP petrochemical sites. Later he managed major capital projects before taking on greater commercial and leadership roles, soon running a number of BP business lines, and ultimately taking on senior management and executive roles at BP.
Allan Baker
Global Head of Power, Société Générale
Biography
Allan has been involved in the power sector for more than 25 years, initially as an engineer but for the last 20 years in finance sector. During his career he has advised on and financed a wide range of projects in Asia, the US and EMEA ranging from renewable energy to the acquisition of large power portfolios. This experience has also encompassed regulated, partially deregulated and merchant power markets.
Allan has worked at Société Générale for four years as Global Head of Power Project Finance, having previously worked at Credit Lyonnais for thirteen years in various project finance and management roles. In his current role Allan leads the bank’s strategy for structured finance in the power sector and co-ordinates the execution of the global project finance and advisory business in the sector. As part of this role he is currently leading the bank’s development of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) as a potential business line and is acting as Financial Advisor to the Masdar CCS project in Abu Dhabi and Powerfuel Power IGCC/CCS project in the UK.
Allan has a BSc (Hons) in Mechanical Engineering, an MBA, is a Fellow of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers and a Chartered Engineer.
Prof. Jim Watson
Director, Sussex Energy Group
Biography
Professor Jim Watson is Director of the Sussex Energy Group, University of Sussex and a Research Fellow with the Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research. He has over 15 years' experience of managing and conducting research on a range of energy and climate policy issues. His advisory roles include acting as lead expert with a UK Foresight project on Sustainable Energy Management and the Built Environment (2007-08), and as Specialist Adviser to two House of Commons select committees (2006-11). He was a Visiting Scholar at the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University in 2008. Jim is the 2011 chair of the British Institute for Energy Economics.
Session Four: Laying the ground – developing transport and infrastructure for CCS
15.45
Panel Discussion: Competition vs cooperation in CCS transport and storage details
- Is competing for funding the best way to develop infrastructure?
- Assessing the feasibility of shared transport and storage: where do the synergies lie?
- What are the legal competition considerations in cooperating?
- Should there be a single agent/funding mechanism to oversee infrastructure?
- Is the proposed framework for long-term liabilities adequate?
- How can effective cooperation towards a shared infrastructure be driven?
Questions from the audience
More panellists to be confirmed
Martin Simpson
Head of Energy & Technology, The Crown Estate
Biography
Martin Simpson currently holds the position as Head of Energy & Technology in The Crown Estate with responsibilities including delivery of The Crown Estate's Offshore Wind, Marine, CCS, Gas storage and Technology programmes. Prior to joining The Crown Estate in 2008 Martin held various upstream and R&D Project Management positions in the Energy sector for Shell including a 4 year spell in Shell Wind Energy. In his spare time Martin enjoys outdoor activities including golf, triathlons and hill walking.
Chris Train
Network Operations Director, National Grid
Biography
Chris Train is currently responsible for the real time operation of National Grid’s electricity and gas transmission networks in the UK, forward energy trading and balancing services, operational forecasting, planning and policy.
Chris Train has over 20 years experience within the energy and utility sector. Chris led the National Grid acquisitions of Keyspan and New England Gas in the north east US. These transactions followed the successful sale of half of National Grid’s UK gas distribution Networks.
In his early career Chris held a number of engineering regulation and commercial positions. Chris is a Chartered Engineer and a member of the Energy Institute, the Institution of Gas Engineers and Managers, and the Chartered Institute of Marketing. He has extensive experience operating in the commercial and regulatory environment in the UK, US and Europe.
16.15
Shipping CO2: a more flexible transport approach details
- Shipping vs pipelines: benefits and drawbacks
- What are the implications of pressurising vs cooling CO2?
- Capacity and timing flexibility: is shipping an interim or long-term transport solution?
- Addressing the safety concerns: regulation and public perception
Per Lothe
Technology Director, Knutsen OAS Shipping
Session Five: Effectively engaging stakeholders and the public
16.40
Panel Discussion: Winning local and national support for CCS details
- Assessing awareness and perception of CCS on the local and national level
- How does long-term storage affect public acceptance for CCS?
- Do the public perceive parallels between CCS and nuclear?
- Gas vs coal CCS: assessing the implications for public acceptance
- Is there any point in a PR campaign before the technology is commercially ready?
Questions from the audience
Marc Kombrink
Manager Communications and Public Engagement, Road 2020
Biography
Marc Kombrink is manager Communications & Public Engagement of the Rotterdam Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) Demonstration project, one of the six CCS demonstration projects within the framework of the European Energy Programme for Recovery (EEPR). As a communications professional Marc Kombrink has over 15 years of experience on both the agency and the client side. Previously, he worked as senior advisor Corporate Communications & Public Affairs at Eneco (one of the leading Dutch utilities) being responsible for external communications and stakeholders & reputation management. Furthermore, he was a communications consultant at leading communication agencies, such as Deloitte & Touch Consulting Group/Public Affairs Consultants, Burson-Marsteller and TMPW Worldwide Advertising & Communications. Marc Kombrink studied Public Administration at the Erasmus University of Rotterdam.
Dr David Reiner
Director, Electricity Policy Research Group, University of Cambridge
Biography
David Reiner is Course Director of the MPhil in Technology Policy and University Senior Lecturer in Technology Policy at Judge Business School, University of Cambridge. He is also Assistant Director of the Electricity Policy Research Group at Cambridge, and research associate of the Carbon Sequestration Initiative at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Current research activities include international surveys of public and stakeholder perceptions of carbon dioxide capture and storage technologies, public communications on science and technology, studies of siting controversies over large-scale energy supply infrastructure, regular surveys in the UK of energy consuming behaviour and public preferences towards energy policy.
Judy Shapiro
Policy and Communications Manager, CCSa
Chris Littlecott
Senior Policy Adviser, Green Alliance
17.10
Chairman’s closing remarks and end of day one